Best and Most Reliable Hard Drives for Synology NAS Windows Central 2019
Choosing the right hard drives for your network attached storage (NAS) is incredibly important. Western Digital and Seagate are the two giants for storage and both companies offer an almost identical offering specifically designed with servers in mind. This makes it easy to select the right drive(s) for your NAS. However, out of the two we’d go with Seagate because of speeds for the price.
The Seagate IronWolf series is the company’s solution for NAS setups, rivaling the Western Digital Red, but with faster speeds and larger storage capacities available. Similar technology, named AgileArray, is implemented to offer enhanced performance and reliability over desktop drives, and these units can be installed in boxes that support up to eight bays. IronWolf Pro is the next step up with slightly more expensive drives but increased supported bays, workload rates, and a limited warranty.
Most importantly, these drives can be run 24/7 without shutdown. The IronWolf family of NAS hard drives come in 1TB, 2TB, 3TB, 4TB, 6TB, 8TB, 10TB, 12TB, 14TB, and 16TB versions and with three-year warranties. Prices start at $60 for the 1TB capacity configuration but can cap out at more than $500. Do note that only configurations of 4TB and above sport rotational vibration sensors. The 6TB and above models run at 7,200 RPM.
If you want the best of what Seagate has to offer in terms of NAS storage, have a look at the IronWolf Pro series. All the Pro drives spin at 7,200 RPM and can handle 250MB/s of sustained data transfer, with bursts of around 6Gb/s. There’s also an extended 5-year warranty and a 300TB per year workload limit. The Pro line of Seagate IronWolf drives also support up to 24 bays.
- Great value
- 6TB and up run at 7,200 RPM
- 5,400 RPM at lower sizes
- Up to 8 bays
Best for NAS
Hard drives designed for NAS
Seagate has a strong collection of drives that are specifically designed for use inside NAS. The higher capacity drives even have faster motors.
For NAS pros
When you require a more powerful NAS
These drives are super-fast, packing in 7,200RPM motors that can allow for up to 250MB/s of sustained data transfer, with bursts of around 6Gb/s.
Much like Seagate, WD has been making storage solutions for PCs for many years and it offers reliable drives for any NAS. As with the Seagate drives, I recommend at least 4TB. WD’s Red hard drives are manufactured for NAS use and can be deployed in systems that support up to eight bays. Backed by 3-year limited warranties and a powerful brand in the storage market, WD drives are well known to be of top quality, and they last a long time. Red isn’t the fastest hard drive series on the market, but using them in a RAID formation can make up for this.
This particular series of drives comes in 1TB, 2TB, 3TB, 4TB, 6TB, 8TB and 10TB versions. Depending on just how much space you require, it’s possible to pick one up for as little as $64 (1TB). Each drive comes with the company’s NASware 3.0 for enhanced reliability and performance. It’s also worth noting that WD doesn’t ship any mounting brackets or screws with these drives.
What makes WD drives appealing is the fact that every capacity option has vibration protection, but if you need faster speeds (drives that run at 7,200 RPM) you will need to fork out more for the Red Pro series.
- Great value
- All have vibration sensors
- Up to 8 bays
- All run at 5,400 RPM
Perfect hard drives for your NAS
Western Digital has been making storage solutions for PCs for many years, offering reliable but somewhat slower drives for your NAS.
For the pros
When normal NAS drives just won’t do
Western Digital’s pro series of drives are even more capable and can support up to 24 bays, come with a 5-year warranty and more advantage features.
Whether you go with Seagate or Western Digital, it’s always a good idea to pick up a hard drive designed for NAS use. All of the drives mentioned here fit that bill. While you can technically use a traditional desktop-class drive, I’d recommend against doing so. Desktop-class hard drives aren’t designed to be operating continuously and they’re not backed by extended warranties, nor do they come with advanced protective features you find on NAS drives.
Seagate comes out slightly on top since Western Digital doesn’t offer any 7,200 RPM drives unless you pay more for the Red Pro series. Everything else is pretty much identical between the two storage families. This extra speed found in higher capacity drives from Seagate means increased access speeds, which is important for storing and loading files on your server. Looking for hard drives to install into your NAS? Go with the Seagate IronWolf.
Credits — The team that worked on this guide
Rich Edmonds is a staff reviewer at Windows Central, which means he tests out more software and hardware than he cares to remember. Joining Mobile Nations in 2010, you can usually find him inside a PC case tinkering around when not at a screen fighting with Grammarly to use British words. Hit him up on Twitter: @RichEdmonds.
Cale Hunt is a full-time writer for Windows Central, focusing mainly on PC hardware and VR. He is an avid PC gamer and multi-platform user, and when he has some free time you can usually find him practicing guitar or reorganizing his ever-growing library. If you hear him say “Sorry!” it’s only because he’s Canadian.
We may earn a commission for purchases using our links. Learn more.